The Birthmark Analysis by Nathaniel Hawthorne

Nathaniel Hawthorne’s short story “The Birthmark” is a thought-provoking tale that explores themes of perfection, science, nature, and human hubris. Published in 1843, this story continues to captivate readers with its rich symbolism and profound questions about the human condition.

In this post, we’ll break down the key elements of the story and provide a detailed critical analysis.

Plot Summary

Before we dive into the analysis, let’s quickly recap the story:

Aylmer, a brilliant scientist, marries the beautiful Georgiana. Georgiana has a small, hand-shaped birthmark on her cheek, which Aylmer sees as a flaw in her otherwise perfect beauty. Obsessed with removing this “imperfection,” Aylmer convinces Georgiana to undergo a dangerous procedure to remove the birthmark. Despite initial hesitation, Georgiana agrees, driven by her love for Aylmer and her own growing insecurity about the mark.

Aylmer, assisted by his servant Aminadab, creates a potion to remove the birthmark. Georgiana drinks it and falls into a deep sleep. As she sleeps, the birthmark fades away, but so does Georgiana’s life force. She wakes briefly, sees that the birthmark is gone, and dies, leaving Aylmer to face the consequences of his obsession with perfection.

Character Analysis

Aylmer

Aylmer is the protagonist of the story, though his actions are far from heroic. Let’s break down his character:

1. Brilliant but flawed: Aylmer is a respected scientist with a keen intellect. However, his brilliance is overshadowed by his obsession with perfection.
2. Hubris: Aylmer’s fatal flaw is his excessive pride and overconfidence in his scientific abilities. He believes he can improve upon nature itself.
3. Symbolism of science: Aylmer represents the scientific pursuit of knowledge and control over nature, often at the expense of human values and emotions.
4. Lack of acceptance: He is unable to accept imperfection, even in something as minor as a birthmark on his wife’s face.
5. Tragic figure: Despite his intentions to “perfect” his wife, Aylmer’s actions lead to tragedy, making him a classic example of a tragic hero brought down by his own flaws.

Example: Aylmer’s hubris is evident when he says, “I feel myself fully competent to render this dear cheek as faultless as its fellow; and then, most beloved, what will be my triumph when I shall have corrected what Nature left imperfect in her fairest work!”

Georgiana

Georgiana is Aylmer’s wife and the bearer of the titular birthmark. Her character is crucial to understanding the story’s themes:

1. Symbol of natural beauty: Georgiana represents nature’s beauty, which includes both perfection and imperfection.
2. Victim of societal standards: She internalizes Aylmer’s obsession with her birthmark, showing how societal standards of beauty can affect self-perception.
3. Loyalty and love: Georgiana’s willingness to risk her life to please Aylmer demonstrates her deep love and loyalty.
4. Inner conflict: She struggles between accepting herself and wanting to meet her husband’s expectations.
5. Tragic figure: Georgiana’s death symbolizes the destruction of natural beauty in the pursuit of artificial perfection.

Example: Georgiana’s inner conflict is clear when she says, “Life is but a sad possession to those who have attained precisely the degree of moral advancement at which I stand. Were I weaker and blinder, it might be happiness. Were I stronger, it might be endured hopefully. But, being what I find myself, methinks I am of all mortals the most fit to die.”

Aminadab

Though a minor character, Aminadab plays a significant role in the story:

1. Contrast to Aylmer: Aminadab represents the earthly and physical, in contrast to Aylmer’s intellectual and spiritual pursuits.
2. Voice of reason: His laughter and comments often serve as a warning or critique of Aylmer’s actions.
3. Symbol of nature: Aminadab’s earthy nature and connection to the physical world contrast with Aylmer’s attempts to transcend nature.

Example: Hawthorne describes Aminadab as “a man of low stature, but bulky frame, with shaggy hair hanging about his visage, which was grimed with the vapors of the furnace.”

Themes and Symbolism

The Pursuit of Perfection

One of the central themes in “The Birthmark” is the dangerous obsession with perfection:

1. Unattainable ideal: The story suggests that human perfection is an unattainable goal.
2. Destructive pursuit: Aylmer’s quest for perfection ultimately destroys the very thing he sought to perfect.
3. Nature vs. artifice: The conflict between natural beauty (represented by Georgiana) and artificial perfection (Aylmer’s goal) is a key theme.
4. Societal standards: The story critiques societal standards of beauty and perfection that can be harmful and unrealistic.

Example: The destructive nature of this pursuit is evident in the story’s tragic ending, where Georgiana dies as her “imperfection” is removed.

Science vs. Nature

Another major theme is the conflict between scientific progress and the natural world:

1. Limits of science: The story questions the limits of scientific knowledge and human ability to control nature.
2. Ethical considerations: It raises ethical questions about the use of science to alter natural phenomena.
3. Hubris of scientists: Aylmer’s downfall serves as a cautionary tale about scientific hubris.
4. Balance: The story suggests the need for balance between scientific progress and respect for natural processes.

Example: Aylmer’s laboratory, described as a place where “the most splendid successes have been achieved,” becomes the site of his greatest failure, highlighting the limits of scientific control over nature.

The Nature of Humanity

“The Birthmark” also delves into what it means to be human:

1. Imperfection as human: The story suggests that imperfections are an integral part of being human.
2. Mortality: Georgiana’s death after the removal of her birthmark implies that mortality is tied to our imperfections.
3. Acceptance: The tale emphasizes the importance of accepting oneself and others, flaws and all.
4. Love and superficiality: It questions the nature of love and whether it should be conditional on physical perfection.

Example: When Georgiana says, “If there be the remotest possibility of it, let the attempt be made at whatever risk,” she shows a tragic willingness to risk her humanity for an ideal of perfection.

Symbolism of the Birthmark

The birthmark itself is rich in symbolism:

1. Human imperfection: It represents the flaws inherent in all humans.
2. Mortality: Its hand shape suggests the hand of death, foreshadowing Georgiana’s fate.
3. Connection to nature: The birthmark’s crimson color ties it to life and nature.
4. Individuality: It makes Georgiana unique, suggesting that our “flaws” are part of our identity.
5. Gender dynamics: Its presence on a woman’s face can be read as a commentary on societal beauty standards for women.

Example: Hawthorne describes the birthmark as “the visible mark of earthly imperfection,” directly stating its symbolic significance.

Literary Techniques

Hawthorne employs various literary techniques to enhance the story’s impact:

Foreshadowing

Throughout the story, Hawthorne drops hints about the tragic ending:

1. Aylmer’s dream of cutting out Georgiana’s heart to remove the birthmark.
2. The descriptions of the birthmark deepening in color when Georgiana blushes, linking it to her life force.
3. The failure of Aylmer’s previous experiments, hinting at the danger of his pursuits.

Example: “With the morning twilight Aylmer opened his eyes upon his wife’s face and recognized the symbol of imperfection; and when they sat together at the evening hearth his eyes wandered stealthily to her cheek, and beheld, flickering with the blaze of the wood fire, the spectral hand that wrote mortality where he would fain have worshipped.”

Imagery

Hawthorne uses vivid imagery to create a mood and convey deeper meanings:

1. The laboratory is described in terms that make it seem otherworldly and slightly sinister.
2. The birthmark is repeatedly described in ways that emphasize its connection to Georgiana’s life and humanity.
3. Contrasts between light and dark, earthly and spiritual, are used throughout the story.

Example: “The scene around her was like enchantment. Aylmer had converted those smoky, dingy, sombre rooms, where he had spent his brightest years in recondite pursuits, into a series of beautiful apartments not unfit to be the secluded abode of a lovely woman.”

Allegory

The entire story can be read as an allegory for larger themes:

1. The dangers of playing God or trying to perfect nature.
2. The conflict between science and nature.
3. The destructive power of obsession and the inability to accept imperfection.

Example: Aylmer’s pursuit of removing the birthmark can be seen as an allegory for humanity’s broader attempts to control and perfect nature through science.

Irony

Irony plays a significant role in the story:

1. Situational irony: Aylmer’s attempt to perfect Georgiana leads to her death.
2. Dramatic irony: The reader often understands the danger of Aylmer’s actions before the characters do.
3. Verbal irony: Some of Aylmer’s statements about his abilities contrast sharply with the reality of the situation.

Example: The ultimate irony of the story is that in removing Georgiana’s only “imperfection,” Aylmer destroys her completely.

Historical and Cultural Context

Understanding the historical and cultural context of “The Birthmark” can provide deeper insights into its themes and messages:

Scientific Progress in the 19th Century

1. Rapid advancements: The 19th century saw significant scientific progress, which both excited and frightened people.
2. Ethical concerns: As science advanced, questions arose about the ethical implications of new discoveries and technologies.
3. Changing worldviews: Scientific discoveries were challenging traditional religious and philosophical views.

Example: Aylmer’s confidence in science reflects the optimism of the time, while the story’s outcome reflects anxieties about the limits and dangers of scientific progress.

Transcendentalism

Hawthorne was writing in the context of the Transcendentalist movement in America:

1. Nature and spirituality: Transcendentalists emphasized the importance of nature and individual intuition.
2. Critique of materialism: They were critical of excessive focus on material progress at the expense of spiritual growth.
3. Perfection and self-reliance: The movement emphasized the potential for human perfection through self-reliance.

Example: While not a Transcendentalist himself, Hawthorne engages with these ideas in “The Birthmark,” particularly in his portrayal of nature and the consequences of attempting to perfect it.

Gender Roles in 19th Century America

The story reflects and comments on gender roles of its time:

1. Women as objects of beauty: Georgiana’s value seems to be primarily in her beauty, reflecting societal attitudes.
2. Male dominance: Aylmer’s control over Georgiana reflects the patriarchal nature of 19th-century society.
3. Critique of these norms: The tragic ending can be read as a critique of these gender dynamics.

Example: Georgiana’s willingness to risk her life to meet Aylmer’s standards of beauty reflects the intense pressure on women to conform to societal beauty standards.

Comparative Analysis

Comparing “The Birthmark” to other works can provide additional insights:

Comparison with Other Hawthorne Works

1. “Rappaccini’s Daughter”: Both stories deal with scientists whose pursuits lead to tragedy.
2. “The Scarlet Letter”: Both works explore themes of human imperfection and societal judgment.

Example: Like Aylmer, Rappaccini in “Rappaccini’s Daughter” is a scientist whose experiments have tragic consequences for a young woman.

Comparison with Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein”

1. Scientific hubris: Both stories warn against the dangers of scientific overreach.
2. Playing God: Both feature protagonists who attempt to surpass the limits of nature.
3. Tragic consequences: In both stories, the pursuit of scientific achievement leads to destruction.

Example: Victor Frankenstein, like Aylmer, is driven by scientific ambition to create perfection, with disastrous results.

Comparison with Edgar Allan Poe’s Works

1. Obsession: Like many of Poe’s protagonists, Aylmer is driven by obsession.
2. Gothic elements: Both authors use elements of the Gothic to create atmosphere and tension.

Example: Aylmer’s obsession with the birthmark is reminiscent of the narrator’s obsession with the old man’s eye in Poe’s “The Tell-Tale Heart.”

Critical Reception and Interpretations

“The Birthmark” has been widely analyzed and interpreted since its publication:

Feminist Interpretations

1. Critique of beauty standards: Many feminist critics see the story as a critique of impossible beauty standards imposed on women.
2. Male control over female bodies: Aylmer’s desire to change Georgiana’s appearance is seen as representing broader issues of male control over women’s bodies.

Example: Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar, in their book “The Madwoman in the Attic,” discuss how the story reflects 19th-century attitudes toward women and female beauty.

Scientific Ethics

1. Limitations of science: Many interpret the story as a warning about the limitations and potential dangers of scientific progress.
2. Ethics in scientific pursuit: The story raises questions about the ethics of scientific experimentation and the pursuit of knowledge at any cost.

Example: In his book “Hawthorne’s Fuller Mystery,” Thomas R. Mitchell discusses how the story reflects 19th-century anxieties about scientific progress.

Psychological Interpretations

1. Obsession and perfectionism: Some critics focus on the psychological aspects of Aylmer’s obsession and need for perfection.
2. Projection of inner flaws: Others suggest that Aylmer’s fixation on Georgiana’s birthmark is a projection of his own inner flaws.

Example: Frederick Crews, in “The Sins of the Fathers: Hawthorne’s Psychological Themes,” provides a psychological analysis of Aylmer’s motivations and actions.

Relevance Today

Despite being written in the 19th century, “The Birthmark” remains relevant today:

1. Beauty standards: The story’s critique of unrealistic beauty standards resonates in our image-obsessed culture.
2. Scientific ethics: As we grapple with issues like genetic engineering and AI, the story’s questions about the limits of science remain pertinent.
3. Acceptance of imperfection: In a world that often demands perfection, the story’s message about accepting human flaws is still powerful.
4. Gender dynamics: The story’s exploration of male control over female bodies continues to be a significant issue.

Example: The rise of social media and photo editing technology has created new pressures to appear “perfect,” making Georgiana’s struggle with her perceived flaw feel very modern.

Related Articles

Aylmer’s Motivation in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “The Birthmark”

FAQs

1. Q: What does the birthmark symbolize in the story? A: The birthmark symbolizes human imperfection, mortality, and the connection to nature. It represents the flaws that make us human and individual.
2. Q: Why does Aylmer want to remove the birthmark? A: Aylmer sees the birthmark as a flaw in Georgiana’s otherwise perfect beauty. His desire to remove it stems from his obsession with perfection and his belief in science’s ability to improve upon nature.
3. Q: What is the significance of Aminadab in the story? A: Aminadab serves as a contrast to Aylmer, representing the earthly and physical aspects of life. His reactions often serve as a warning or critique of Aylmer’s actions.
4. Q: How does the story critique scientific progress? A: The story suggests that scientific progress, when taken to extremes, can be dangerous. It warns against the hubris of thinking science can perfect nature and questions the ethics of certain scientific pursuits.
5. Q: What is the moral of “The Birthmark”? A: The story has multiple morals, including the dangers of obsessing over perfection, the importance of accepting human flaws, and the potential dangers of unchecked scientific ambition.
6. Q: How does the story reflect 19th-century attitudes toward women? A: The story reflects and critiques 19th-century attitudes that valued women primarily for their beauty and placed them under male control. Georgiana’s willingness to risk her life to meet Aylmer’s standards of beauty highlights the intense pressures women faced